Direct-hire recruiting · Nationwide

Contact us

What an open role really costs your firm

An empty position never sends an invoice, so it rarely gets priced. Where the cost of an open role actually lands in a financial practice, why waiting makes it grow, and how to put a number on it before deciding a search can wait.

A client service associate gives two weeks’ notice on a Friday. By the following Monday the work has already been handed out. The lead advisor takes the client calls. Someone in operations picks up the paperwork. Scheduling falls to whoever notices it first.

Nothing breaks. That is what makes it expensive.

Nobody invoices you for an empty desk

When a firm decides whether to bring in a recruiter, the recruiter’s fee is the number on the table. It is written down, it has a due date, and somebody has to approve it.

The open role has no number at all. It never shows up on a statement, so it rarely gets weighed against anything. A search gets put off for a month because the fee is visible and the vacancy is not.

The vacancy still costs money. The cost is spread across people’s calendars, where nobody adds it up.

Where the cost lands

In most practices the work of an open support role flows upward, because the people above it know how to do it. A lead advisor who spends eight hours a week on client service is spending eight fewer hours on planning, reviews and new relationships. Those are the hours that produce revenue, and they are the first hours to go.

The people covering pay next. The first few weeks of extra work feel manageable. By the second month the people absorbing it are tired, and they are usually your most capable people, because capable people are the ones who get handed extra work. The quiet risk of a long vacancy is a second resignation from someone who was covering for the first.

Then clients feel it. Response times stretch. A follow-up that used to go out the same day goes out on Thursday. Few clients will mention it, but they notice, and it colors how they feel about the relationship.

Last are the plans you had: the new service line, the move into a second market, the succession work for a retiring advisor. Growth projects slide first when everyone is covering a gap, because they are the only work without a client waiting on it.

Putting a number on it

You can estimate this for your own firm in a few minutes, and your numbers will be better than any industry average.

  1. List the work the open role did, and who is doing it now.
  2. Estimate the hours per week each of those people spends on it.
  3. Put a value on an hour of their time. For an advisor, use what an hour of their work typically produces for the practice. Salary understates it.
  4. Multiply by the number of weeks the role has been open, or realistically will be.

Take the example above. Eight advisor hours a week, for a role that stays open twelve weeks, is 96 hours of the most productive time in the practice spent on work someone else was hired to do. Add the operations hours, and put whatever figure you like on the client who drifted and the project that slipped.

Then set that figure next to the cost of a search. It is the comparison most firms skip, because only one of the two numbers ever arrives on paper.

Waiting makes it more expensive

The natural instinct is to post the job, see who applies, and bring in help only if that does not work. The trouble is that each week of waiting makes the eventual search harder.

Start with who sees the posting. The people you would most like to hire are doing well where they are, and they do not read job boards. A posting reaches the people who are actively looking, which is a smaller and different group. We wrote about this in why the best financial services candidates never see your job ad.

Pressure also changes the decision. A role that has been open for two months gets filled differently from one that has been open for two weeks. The bar drifts. A candidate who would have been a clear no in week one starts to look workable in week nine, and a rushed hire can leave the role open again within the year. If that has happened to you before, our piece on running the next search after a bad hire is worth a read.

And candidates can tell. Good candidates notice when a firm is in a hurry. Urgency shows in how quickly offers arrive and how much room there is in the conversation, and it moves the negotiation in their favor.

Before the next resignation

A few things are worth having in place before you need them.

  • Know which roles would hurt most to lose. Often it is the role whose work nobody else is set up to absorb, and that is seldom the most senior person.
  • Keep a current description of what each role actually does. Job descriptions drift from the real work over time, and rebuilding one from memory under pressure costs days.
  • Know what the role pays in your market today. Finding out mid-search that the budget is short restarts the clock.
  • Decide in advance when you will bring in help, whether that is the day notice arrives or two weeks after the posting goes up. It is an easier call to make before anyone is covering.

Every firm has vacancies. What separates the ones that handle them well is treating the open role as a cost from its first day.

Get in touch

Tell us about the opening

Tell us what the role does and how long it has been open. We will tell you how we would approach the search and what it would take to reach the people who are not looking.

Prefer to talk? (844) 691-4473


Humans Being Resources is a direct-hire recruiting firm placing permanent employees for firms in financial services, accounting and tax, and insurance, in all 50 states.

Google Rating

Based on

000

#set-float-cta-url

How can we help you today?

Get a free quote

Mon - Fri8:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Sat9:00 AM - 3:00 PM

SunClosed

#set-popup-url